Skip to main content

Hunger Games is Chick-Lit and Why That Sucks


When Caleb's 5th grade teacher began reading Hunger Games in class last August, I knew I had to read it. I thoroughly enjoyed the book, as well as the other two in the trilogy. I had a vague sense it was thinly disguised chick-lit and my suspicion has been confirmed.

Haley says so here. Be warned her post contains all kinds of spoilers, as does mine. Haley is a Christian blogger who writes about the dynamics of game (how men can attract women). Her site is a legend of awesomeness.

Before Caleb's teacher finished reading the book to the class, half the girls in the class had bought the rest of the trilogy and finished it. Cue comparisons to Twilight and Harry Potter.

What makes Hunger Games unconventional is that Katniss Everdeen is portrayed as a masculine protagonist who doesn't know how to be feminine. So she has to learn to be a woman kicking and screaming. The trilogy is a coming of age story for the modern woman. It portrays Katniss on a journey towards gender equality - she has to negotiate the difficult feminine terrain of socially-constructed beauty (Cinna's makeover), hide her emotions from the camera, and rescue the dudes (Peeta and Gale) in distress. She seems reluctant and ambivalent about all the attention she receives and all the killing she has to do. Her life is a tension between the masculine and feminine and in the end, she gets to have her cake and eat it too.

I remember Judy warning me not to let Abby watch Taylor Swift's "You belong with me" music video lest she get a false idea of what love is about. I would offer similar advice to young female (and male) readers of the Hunger Games trilogy. Here are some observations:

1) You are not Katniss Everdeen: I'm not talking about archery skills. I'm talking about her personality. I have hard time believing girls that hate killing can do it without an enormous emotional toll. I have hard time believing that tomboys can hate makeovers and having attention showered on them. Heck, I want a Cinna makeover. Stick me in a chariot and set me on fire in front of a million people. I'd kill for that kind of attention.

2) Peeta Mellark and Gale Hawthorne don't exist either: Peeta is the Christ figure who doesn't have the guts to tell Katniss about his crush on her (pre-arena) but has the courage to risk his life for others. Right. Ditto for Gale but Gale never gave her bread ala Matthew 25 so he's a lesser Christ figure. Guess who Katniss chooses?

So what do we learn about this female fantasy? Women enjoy an idealized perception of themselves which translates into unrealistic expectations of men and what romantic love is about. Sounds like the classic chick-lit and chick-flick.
Labels:

Comments

  1. Anne LeeMarch 29, 2012 at 11:23 AM

    Fred, that's harsh! You said you liked the book but your review is tough. Did the boys in the class like the story?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fred MokMarch 29, 2012 at 10:16 PM

      i would say pretty much all the boys enjoyed the story and several of them went on to read the trilogy but it was nowhere as popular with them as it was with the girls in the class. I asked Caleb about it today and he said he might read the rest of the series but there were other books he would be more interested in.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Dad's Review of Passport 2 Purity

[3,100 words, 11 minute read] The sex talk is one of the most dreaded conversations parents anticipate having with their children. To make things easier, an entire industry exists to help parents with sex education. Dozens of books have been written to help parents navigate this treacherous topic with their progeny. One of the best known among evangelicals is called the Passport 2 Purity Getaway package . It is produced by FamilyLife, a division of Cru (former Campus Crusade for Christ) and consists of a five lecture CD package including a journal and exercises designed as a weekend retreat for a pre-pubescent child and his/her parent(s). Passport 2 Purity was not my initiative. Our trip came about because Judy had heard from several home-schooling mom friends how they had taken their daughters on a road trip to go through the CDs. She even heard how a mom took a trip with husband and two sons to through the curriculum. So a couple months ago, Judy suggested we take our two older boy
24 comments
Read more

Asian American Divorce Rate

I can't find recent data. Most of the stuff is at least five years old but by these estimates, the Asian American divorce rate is about 5%. I've got research from 2002 , 2008 for Asian Americans, and 2008 for Chinese Americans. The latest census data do not break out by race. In any case, a 5% divorce rate is about half the national average. Less divorce is a good thing. I would imagine that divorce does not bode well for personal fulfillment and many studies have shown it has a negative impact on children (too lazy to cite all the sources here). Of course, as one source argues, a lower divorce rate does not equate to a healthy marriage. There can be all kinds of abuse, dysfunction, and strife within marriage. All in all though, a lower divorce rate is one advantage of late marriage for Asian American men (and women). However, I believe a lower divorce rate is correlated with later marriage and there is no causation between the two. People who tend to be conservative,
4 comments
Read more

Why Asians Run Slower

My brother got me David Epstein's book The Sports Gene . It is a fascinating quick read. If you're interested in sports and science, it will enthrall you.  I finished it in three days. Epstein's point is that far more of an athlete's performance is due to genetics than due to the so-called "10,000 hour" rule promulgated by books such as Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell and Talent is Overrated by Geoff Colvin (both which are very good). The 10,000 hour rule states that any person can reach expert level of performance in a sport if they devote 10,000 hours of deliberate and intentional practice.  That's a lot of hours. Most people aren't capable of anywhere close. And that's precisely Epstein's point. Someone who devotes 10,000 hours of sport-specific practice is likely genetically gifted for the sport in extraordinary ways AND genetically gifted in their ability to persevere and benefit from practice. Therefore, a person who can pra
4 comments
Read more